Measuring web application performance
Posted April 22, 2012on:
Going by the many posts in various LinkedIn groups and blogs, there seems to be some confusion about how to measure and analyze a web application’s performance. This article tries to clarify the different aspects of web performance and how to go about measuring it, explaining key terms and concepts along the way.
Web Application Architecture
The diagram below shows a high-level view of typical architectures of web applications.
The simplest applications have the web and app tiers combined while more complex ones may have multiple application tiers (called “middleware”) as well as multiple datastores.
The Front end refers to the web tier that generates the html response for the browser.
The Back end refers to the server components that are responsible for the business logic.
Note that in architectures where a single web/app server tier is responsible for both the front and back ends, it is still useful to think of them as logically separate for the purposes of performance analysis.
Front End Performance
When measuring front end performance, we are primarily concerned with understanding the response time that the user (sitting in front of a browser) experiences. This is typically measured as the time taken to load a web page. Performance of the front end depends on the following:
- Time taken to generate the base page
- Browser parse time
- Time to download all of the components on the page (css,js,images,etc.)
- Browser render time of the page
For most applications, the response time is dominated by the 3rd bullet above i.e. time spent by the browser in retrieving all of the components on a page. As pages have become increasingly complex, their sizes have mushroomed as well – it is not uncommon to see pages of 0.5 MB or more. Depending on where the user is located, it can take a significant amount of time for the browser to fetch components across the internet.
Front end Performance Tools
Front-end performance is typically viewed as waterfall charts produced by tools such as the Firebug Net Panel. During development, firebug is an invaluable tool to understand and fix client-side issues. However, to get a true measure of end user experience on production systems, performance needs to be measured from points on the internet where your customers typically are. Many tools are available to do this and they vary in price and functionality. Do your research to find a tool that fits your needs.
Back End Performance
The primary goal of measuring back end performance is to understand the maximum throughput that it can sustain.Traditionally, enterprises perform “load testing” of their applications to ensure they can scale. I prefer to call this “scalability testing“. Test clients drive load via bare-bones HTTP clients and measure the throughput of the application i.e. the number of requests per second they can handle. To increase the throughput, the number of client drivers need to be increased until the point where throughput stops to increase or worse stops to drop-off.
For complex multi-tier architectures, it is beneficial to break-up the back end analysis by testing the scalability of individual tiers. For example, database scalability can be measured by running a workload just on the database. This can greatly help identify problems and also provides developers and QA engineers with tests they can repeat during subsequent product releases.
Many applications are thrown into production before any scalability testing is done. Things may seem fine until the day the application gets hit with increased traffic (good for business!). If the application crashes and burns because it cannot handle the load, you may not get a second chance.
Back End Performance Tools
Numerous load testing tools exist with varying functionality and price. There are also a number of open source tools available. Depending on resources you have and your budget, you can also outsource your entire scalability testing.
Front end performance is primarily concerned with measuring end user response times while back end performance is concerned with measuring throughput and scalability.